December 31, 2011

TGT # 3 - Isocrates

The selections in The Great Tradition are from throughout Isocrates' works, which were well known in his own time and translated into many languages in the following centuries. The first selection, from Against the Sophists, centers on the false teachers and philosophers undermining the quality of education. One of his more interesting observations is that many of these teachers claim to know things about the future, yet "Homer, who has been conceded the highest reputation for wisdom, has pictured the gods at times debating among themselves about the future-not that he knew their minds but that he desired to show us that for mankind this power lies in the realms of the impossible" (TGT 40). I am reminded of the many theorists and forecasters who attempt (and at this time of year in particular) to make predictions about the future...

Another thing that struck me was Isocrates' description of political discourse (he was himself an orator) as a creative process, requiring skill and imagination:
"But I marvel when I observe these men setting themselves up as instructors of youth who cannot see that they are applying the analogy of an art with hard and fast rules to a creative process. For, excepting these teachers, who does not know that the art of using letters remains fixed and unchanged, so that we continually and invariably use the same letters for the same purposes, while exactly the reverse is true of the art of discourse? For what has been said by one speaker is not equally useful for the speaker who comes after him; on the contrary, he is accounted most skilled in this art who speaks in a manner worthy of his subject and yet is able to discover in it topics which are nowise the same as those used by others [...] oratory is good only if it has the qualities of fitness for the occasion, propriety of style, and originality of treatment, while in the case of letters there is no such need whatsoever" (TGT 42).  Isocrates tells us that experience is a perfectly good teacher, that having an aptitude and then working hard to understand one's subject will yield the best results. Ultimately, this kind of study will result in "honesty of character" even if it doesn't produce great orators. I think the same basic principle could be applied to pretty much any area of study. In the next section, Isocrates seems to agree with me.

The selection from the Panathenaicus begins with mild praise for the "education which was handed down from our ancestors" as well as the newer study of geometry, astronomy, and a particular kind of argumentative dialogue that young men seem to enjoy. Isocrates basically says well, at least they're not running in the road. Yet, he does not see these branches of study leading their practitioners to virtuous, balanced lives. Rather than measuring education or cultivation by excellence in a particular science, even oratory, Isocrates suggests that those who exercise good judgment in their daily affairs, who are decent, honorable, moderate, brave in the face of misfortune, and humble in the wake of success are the "wise and complete men" (TGT 44).

We proceed into a selection from the Antidosis, longer than the others, begins with a discussion of physical and mental training. Teachers in both areas can make men better, but "neither class of teachers is in possession of a science by which they can make capable athletes or capable orators out of whomsoever they please" (TGT 45-6).  Isocrates seems to see some men as irredeemably petty and corrupted, but even these can be in some measure improved if they would be willing to follow his basic model of education:

1 - natural aptitude
2 - submission to training and mastery of subject
3 - use/application of knowledge

He goes into some detail about the relationship between natural ability and practice - those who are neglectful of their talents will not do as well as even the less naturally gifted who work harder. Yep.

Isocrates offers a defense of himself as a teacher of youth (not a corrupter of youth) essentially accusing naysayers of hypocrisy.  This goes on for quite some time. Isocrates was a very clever man.



Well, that's it for now. Up next is Aristotle, and after that is Cicero, so we will be in good company for the next few months :o)

December 29, 2011

a week (not) in the kitchen

I made a big (big) pot of veggie curry when we got back from MI on Monday and we've been eating it all week. It is pretty tasty, all tofu/green bean/potato/basil/bell pepper goodness. I was (mostly) enjoying not having to cook dinner (and my lunches graduated to "semi-elaborate") but eating the same thing every night was starting to be a bit maddening.  Tonight, the horrible thought of eating the same thing again combined with wanting to go for a walk, so we went around the block for Thai food. I don't think there's a lesson here, at least not a broad and/or sweeping one, but I won't be making more than one leftover's worth of dinner again any time soon.

December 1, 2011

TGT #2 - Xenophon

Please pretend that it is the end of November and not the first day of December. As usual, please forgive my ignorance, my inconsistent style, and my fondness for parenthetical asides.


As one would expect, these selections from the works of Xenophon (Memorabilia book IV) are primarily a discussion of virtue - what leads men to it, and away from it.  Through Xenophon, Socrates gives us the building blocks of a natural morality, based on humility, education, and wise judgment. The selection begins with Socrates reminding us that those most gifted are both those most in need of a good education, and those most resistant to it: "'Only a fool' he said, 'can think it possible to distinguish between things useful and things harmful without learning: only a fool can think that without distinguishing these he will get all he wants by means of his wealth and be able to do what is expedient: only a simpleton can think that without the power to do what is expedient he is doing well and has made good or sufficient provision for his life: only a simpleton can think that by his wealth alone and without knowledge he will be reputed good at something, or will enjoy a good reputation without being reputed good at anything in particular'" (TGT 30).  (We all could name plenty of people who are famous for being famous, but could you claim that any one of them has a "good reputation?")

Pride, helped along by material possession or false self-knowledge (I'm so great!) leads one to be less effective in reaching any goal worth fighting for - namely, attaining virtue and living in a virtuous society.  When addressing the intellectual pride of a rising politician by the name of Euthydemus, Socrates tells the others: "'I fancy he has prepared a noble exordium to his addresses, with due care not to give the impression that he is indebted to anyone for his knowledge'" (TGT 31).  Originality seems so much bolder, so much smarter, than admitting to or relying on one's predecessors. Yet we would not put up with this attitude in craftsmen, or doctors, so why should we accept it from politicians.

Later on, Socrates meets with Euthydemus alone and tries to show him more specifically what keeps intelligent men from attaining virtue, or acting correctly. He starts on firm footing, by congratulating Euthy (yes, that makes him sound like an anime character, but it saves me some typing) for investing in so many books, saying: "'while gold and silver cannot make men better, the thoughts of the wise enrich their possessors with virtue'" (TGT 31). And virtue, of course, is the problem. When Socrates and Euthy try to organize actions into "just" and "unjust" columns, it becomes clear that correct action is very difficult, and depends much on circumstances and intention. It isn't enough to own the right books, or know them by heart, knowledge must resolve itself into action, which is always the tricky part.

From this demonstration of man's limitations in judgment, we move directly into the oh-so-famous "know thyself" section.  As Maddie pointed out, this is a phrase that is itself entirely emptied of virtue in modern life. Having self knowledge does not mean recognizing some great limitless potential for super-awesomeness in everything (I'm a rock star! I'm a goddess!) bur rather, it is the much, much less glamorous process of recognizing one's limitations. We expect to know things (everything?) already, because pride tells us we are a rockstargoddessherogenius of epic proportions. Ironically, it is only when that "belief" is challenged and we are forced to really grow and learn that we become powerful in any real sense. Education is a painful process because it challenges smug self-satisfaction and laziness.  This can all sound pretty trite and basic, but we ought to keep saying it because clearly humanity has needed to hear it for an awfully long time.

There is also a really fantastic discussion of "the people" and "popular government" at the end of the selection that points out another thing that we seem to have forgotten *cough*OWS*cough*. That is: "some who have very little not only find it enough, but even manage to save out of it, whereas others cannot live within their means, however large'" (TGT 37). Greed and weakness are everywhere, regardless of social standing, as is virtue.

On the whole, I find Xenophon's Socrates much more readable than Plato's. Xenophon makes Socrates sound much more relatable and (in what might be a trick of translations) much more enjoyable to be around.

Next up: Isocrates.  Then Aristotle! yay! (no, that is not sarcastic, I like Aristotle. And by "like" I mostly mean "I understand/agree with him well enough to be capable of bringing him up in casual or semi-casual conversation without sounding like a complete moron" which should probably not be my primary criterion... Does that count as knowledge of my weaknesses, or the pursuit of knowledge as status? Blah)