Showing posts with label quotations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label quotations. Show all posts

September 7, 2012

box of soap, I have one

**I don't usually write here about religion or politics, but at least this once I am going to. If you know me well enough to think that my opinions might offend you, tune in later for all the latest in cooking, laundry, sewing, and vacation photos.**

A friend recently posted a photo on Facebook, which I would like to address here. Alongside a rather well done caricature was this line, attributed to Bertrand Russel "Religion is something left over from the infancy of our intelligence, it will fade away as we adopt reason and science as our guidelines."

Now, I am really, really tired of hearing this. Not angry, because repetition lends an unfortunate dulling effect, but tired. As a religious person I find it insulting, and as someone who values reason I find it insulting. Neither "reason" nor "science," if they were somehow to operate on their own, are capable of inspiring love, mercy, or truly civil society. Period.

Science is a tool for finding out things about the world. The human mind wielding that tool requires a way to make decisions about what is acceptable and what is not. Some of this decision-making is the direct operation of reason, some of it is learned norms and unconscious beliefs. Whatever mixture of elements drive each decision, ethics are unavoidable. It is objectively better that scientists operate with knowledge of their own fallibility and with a strong adherence to a moral code (a moral code that came from somewhere outside their own minds, corrupt machines cannot fix themselves). "Religion" does not hold back "Science" from doing things truly worthwhile for humanity, quite the opposite. The examples of science unrestrained by mercy doubles as a list of atrocities. The same cannot be said of science working through the hands and minds of the merciful.

Every single human being has a code by which they operate, that helps each of us deal with the physical world and with other people. Hopefully these codes are guided by reason, by our higher faculties, but reason alone cannot explain love, or employ it to anyone's benefit. Like science, reason is a tool. Those who respect their tools learn how and when to use them properly. I wouldn't use a screwdriver to hammer nails, and I won't use reason unguided by morality to determine my beliefs or my actions.

The assertion that religion is juvenile or primitive seems to follow from one of the following syllogisms:
1 - "As a child I thought my parents were gods, but I didn't like their rules and they turned out to be just people, therefore anything that requires belief in a higher power will be equally corrupt and meaningless"
2 - "Back in the religious days before the Enlightenment people were sad all the time and didn't have technology or good medicine, I like technology and medicine, therefore I should outgrow religion."

Neither of these stand up well under further examination:
1 - The whole point is that God isn't a fallible person like your parents, and that His will (*cough* rules *cough*) is objectively and eternally true. Whether you find following those rules difficult or uncomfortable is irrelevant to their being true. You have to clean your room because your mother said so, but also because wallowing in your own filth is bad. Ordering your mind and ordering your room are directly related concepts.
2 - I like foreign foods, dental hygiene, and living past 60 as much as the next person, but there are more important things. Being able to read past dark is awfully nice, but if I am only reading garbage novels and neglecting my education (not to mention my eternal soul) then the light bulb is useless. Any serious student of the ancient world can tell you that on the human level it looks a lot like ours. Sophocles, Dante, and Shakespeare are completely readable because people haven't changed; we haven't "evolved" or matured out of needing to relate to other people and to the divine. The Enlightenment made not believing in God sound justifiable, but it did not make it a good idea.

Pretending that you can use a screwdriver to hammer nails is juvenile. Knowing where the hammer is, and where the nails need to go, is the province of religion.

Reason and science cannot fix broken human nature, because they are parts of that broken nature. Only religion can do that. And I don't mean "religion" in the broad sense, or fuzzy happy pseudo-religious feelings. I mean my religion, which I truly believe to be the best and therefore the only answer to these questions.

This is just a cursory glance at very large issues, and is as much an exercise for me as it is intended to instruct anyone else. I welcome private discussion of these and related topics. Questions might include "why are you a (small r) republican monarchist agrarian" or "why don't you think that universal adult suffrage is a good thing" or "can I please have that vegan biscuit recipe you keep going on about."  The last one will be the easiest to answer, but I'll do my best with the others :o)

August 28, 2011

breakdown


Today was witness to our first pre-wedding breakdown. No, it wasn't me. It wasn't G. It wasn't our parents, it was just the car. Thankfully it seems like things are under control, we are fine, and hopefully the car will be as well. G is back in OH with my car, and his is under the supervision of my family's mechanic. 

My first attempt at making my veil ended badly. The shape was right (in theory...), but the material was wrong. Today I acquired the right kind of veiling (in the best fabric store I have ever seen!), and things are coming together nicely. After purchasing the veiling, but before the breakdown, we went to the restaurant where we are having our post-reception family dinner next Sunday - I am still happily full, sooo good!  


It is Carol Lombard day on TCM and I've got to say that movie writing was much better in the '30s.
from Nothing Sacred, c. 1937:

"I hope he's as nice as you"
"He's[...] sort of a cross between a ferris wheel and a werewolf"

October 15, 2010

linear perspective


"Yet every student ought to know that mastery is acquired by resolved limitation"
- Lord Acton, 1895

so quoteth the generalist...

I've always just sort of assumed that the lines of my education would resolve into a single point, or, barring that, would be a reasonably interesting connect-the-dot puzzle (or a portolan map? yes, I am becoming a cartography nerd...). So far things do seem to tend in that direction, but only if I step back enough to get reasonable perspective. Up close my interests seem rather absurdly varied. Oh, well.

May 24, 2010

Swamp story



While in Louisiana last week I happened to find myself on a tour of the Honey Island Swamp (a really lovely place, for a swamp). Anywhoo, our boat was populated mainly by Australian and English tourists, alongside a smattering of locals and a few out of state visitors such as myself. Towards the end of the tour, as we cruised back down the river, we stopped to ogle a group of wild pigs - not much over a year old. The guide began to throw marshmallows (kept on board because alligators like them) to the pigs. Each of the adorable, horrid little things made quite a show of itself to get to the new delicacy before its brother. After a bit, the guide decided to try another trick they use with the alligators = half-a-hot dog-on-a-stick. Yes, hot dog. After a few successful attempts, one English tourist on my side of the boat exclaimed loudly:
*imagine that I am putting on my very best Queen's English*


"You can't feed sausage to a pig, it's just not acceptable"


now
1) they were, in fact, beef hot dogs, and
2) pigs are cannabalistic in the wild

but the English guy's comedic timing was perfect and the whole boat was shaking with laughter. The guide just tore another hot dog in half and clucked softly to the pigs.





February 20, 2010

I am adding another name


to the list of the dead authors I am a little bit in love with.

a few lines from Alexander Pope:

Know then thyself, presume not God to scan;
The proper study of mankind is man.
Placed on this isthmus of a middle state,
A being darkly wise, and rudely great:
With too much knowledge for the skeptic side
With too much weakness for the Stoic's pride,
He hangs between; in doubt to act, or rest,
In doubt to deem himself a god or beast;
In doubt his mind or body to prefer,
Born but to die, and reasoning but to err;
Alike in ignorance, his reason is such,
Wether he thinks too little or too much:
Chaos of thought and passion, all confused;
Still by himself abused, or disabused;
Created half to rise, and half to fall;
Great lord of all things, yet a prey to all;
Sole judge of truth, in endless error hurled:
The glory, jest, and riddle of the world!

- from his Epistle 2, Of the Nature and State of Man with Respect to Himself, as an Individual

*sigh*

March 17, 2009

the words of another



"I can tell you I am as happy as perhaps the Creation can make me: I enjoy all of the Necessities and most of the Conveniences of Life; I have a peaceful Study, as a Refuge from the Hurries and Noise of the world around me; the venerable Dead are waiting in my Library to entertain me, and relieve me from the Nonsense of surviving Mortals"
-Samuel Davies 1751

what wonderful things one finds while researching